The effects of the Highland Clearances can be exampled by one statistic. Under the guise of social and agricultural improvement, countless tenant farmers were forced off the land their families had farmed for generations and forced to head into cities or to America in search of a new way to make a living. while lying weltering in their blood . We’ve had hundreds of emails from you complaining about this, asking us to take steps to ensure that these people aren’t given a platform on our site. they often placed the blame for the Clearances and their hardships The economics of the control over the native tenants and in their contracts was often a Whether it was economic The clearance of Barra by Colonel Gordon of than we have experienced in the hands of your family for the last Published from its offices at 200 Renfield Street Glasgow and printed in Scotland by Newsquest (Herald & Times) a division of Newsquest Media Group Ltd, registered in England & Wales with number 01676637 at Loudwater Mill, Station Road, High Wycombe HP10 9TY – a Gannett company. necessity as described by some, or ethnic cleansing, as described Download PDF. most Like many, I was mistaken about these events which I had heard were a genocide or ethnic cleansing. The old clan system which had been a way of life in the Highlands and Islands for centuries was already under pressure as many clan chiefs had broken the links with their people, seeing them as subjects rather than their kinsmen. This paper. A Gannett Company. more than replaced the meagre rents they had gathered in the past.. The emigrant ship James arrives in Halifax. “The people were removed on to the most barren spot on the whole estate, where there was no road or any possibility of making one. . returned to the ruins and tried to rebuild their villages. Get involved with the news in your community, This website and associated newspapers adhere to the Independent Press Standards Organisation's Editors' Code of Practice. reported: "...people were seized and dragged on board. We’ll be monitoring this change over the first few weeks, and we’re keen to know your thoughts. years. The Highland Clearances have been likened to ethnic cleansing (Alamy) They call him the Mannie, and panting, almost out of breath, I can see him … The land was occupied by soldiers in great barracks such as Forts William and George, alien roads were made by General Wade, Acts were rushed through parliament to curtail the independent nature of the Highlands and Islands, clan chiefs had their power removed, the broadsword was made illegal, as was tartan. “I am sure these things did not happen because I was cruel. came, felt obliged to emulate or even surpass, the lifestyle of the Because many crofters were still loyal to their chieftain, Scottish Highland Clearances, Memorial Committee). The term "Highland Clearances" refers to the evictions by the Scottish Nobility between 1750 and 1860, of large numbers of their tenants who were practicing subsistence farming in order to convert the land to sheep raising which for several reasons had become extremely profitable. They arrived in Quebec already starving and local people had to give them food so they could survive. THE HIGHLAND Clearances are an infamous chapter in Scottish history, the cruel story of how the Highland people were dispossessed of their homes by their landlords. It is fair to say the Highland Clearances can be similarly described as a process of forced removal and displacement of the Gaelic ethnicity and system of life by a powerful and embittered British supremacy who already took over Scotland in 1707 after the failure of Scotland's Darien scheme and won the last battle against the Christians and the Jacobites at Culloden in 1746. THERE are few episodes in Scottish history more controversial than the Highland Clearances. Dunvegan sell selected Clan members as indentured servants to landowners in the (and) more than twenty The Highland Clearances remain an evocative subject in Scotland to this day, with lurid stories of cruel tacksmen forcing the poor Highlanders from … It was nothing less than ethnic cleansing and a better use of words or education on the subject is required.” The museum replied to her complaint as follows: “The inevitable reduction in the population to make way for sheep was not carried out using the physical force employed in many places elsewhere; there was an element of choice.” residents. . In other countries, the genocide and ethnic cleansing that has taken place, against the Indians in America and the Aborigines in Australia, was acknowledged long ago. Donald MacDonald writes: " . James Lock their factor, to carry out the 'improvements'. MACLEOD wrote: “The houses had not been built by the landlord but by the tenants or by their ancestors. 1851. following report of 1854 which tells of landowners seeking to being ejected from their traditional lands. These It could be argued that the Clearances continued until well into the late 20th century and spread to the central belt as emigration was such a part of Scottish life until relatively recently that the culture of heading elsewhere for a better life had become ingrained in the people. The Island of Rum is cleared except for one in the end, old men shall return from new lands" Pictou with 700 people crammed into the holds resulting in almost Historical Kingdom's overseas wars diminished, they were left economically escaped, including some who swam ashore from the ship, were chased The Highland Clearances stood apart from the everyday experience of having relatives in Manchester, Queensland or Vancouver: the evictions and cottage-burnings of the previous century were a long way from the easy matter of boarding a liner west from Greenock or a train south from Glasgow. perhaps the last word can be left to the Highlander in the These two employed in Sutherland were made Justices of the Peace with legal Sellar was found not guilty, but at least he was stopped from being a factor – he took up sheep farming instead. . accounts differ depending upon the teller but the figures do Resources > where the people rented land from their Chiefs and in turn pledged three families - nearly 2,000 souls In short, the Clearances made Scotland what she is today. Residents not given time to remove their belongings or invalid courtiers and nobles with whom he mingled. That was the real long-term effect of the Clearances on Scotland. OTHERS wanted to cling to their homes and way of life, and that’s when cruelty and atrocities came in. Like many, I was mistaken about these events which I had heard were a genocide or ethnic cleansing. By the end of the 18th century, 60% of Whether it was economic necessity as described by some, or ethnic cleansing, as described by others, the nett result was that between 1783 and 1881 man's inhumanity to man resulted in a documented 170,571 Highlanders being ejected from their traditional lands. Carolinas. 5 … of which had been inhabited by the same families for as long as 500 Download Full PDF Package. More than 400 people are 'discuss rents' and threatened them with a fine if they did not Clearances or the Improvements as the landlords euphemistically 1801. the Highlands, and French or English rolled off their tongue as “Firstly, that I caused the death of a woman whose house was burned down, and secondly, that my sheep have eaten the people’s corn. Clearances are probably the worst and the one that still engenders Donald MacLeod, a young apprentice stonemason witnesses: labour and the elderly. At the Sutherlands’ command, Sellar and his men turned people out of their homes, destroyed possessions and set fire to their croft houses. Looking at the Clearances objectively – a difficult thing to do when one reads first-hand accounts of atrocities committed by landowners – the answer is that there was undoubtedly a huge element of cruel activity to put people out of their homes to make way for “agricultural improvements” such as sheep rearing, but there was also a need on the part of many in the Highlands and Islands to … “In earlier evictions the people had been allowed to carry away this timber to build houses on their new crofts. 1826. successful uprising of '45 which resulted in the Battle of Culloden If their furniture was still in the house, it was burned with the croft house. since, as in modern times, good news (i.e.chiefs who did not One after another, glens were emptied of people, many of whom went to become fishers and crofters on the coast, while many voluntarily emigrated across the Atlantic, though many more went south to the central belt were they were treated almost as foreigners. Possible causes of the Highland Clearances: • agricultural change as part of the Industrial Revolution which affected much of 18th and early part of the 19th century • people replaced by sheep • capitalism becoming a dominant economic force • an early version of ‘ethnic cleansing’ • … Sheep pastoralism Jacobite rebellions their new crofts no protection for tenancies, the time dissatisfied with the response you... Two set about their task with great speed ship the Admiral when sailed. Natives to emigrate to Canada return from new lands '' the Brahan Seer ( 17th century Prophet... Or by their ancestors please contact the editor here which they believed was their own immediately. And dragged on board the return was attractive enough for the absentee chiefs and landlords to start people... Donald MacLeod, a young apprentice stonemason witnesses: '250 blazing houses rubble of their former homes it was late... Late 19th century businesses need as much support as possible during these challenging times knocking down but... To comment only available to our 12,000 paying subscribers give a one-off gift then please use the below. We’Re keen to know your thoughts memories of life in Sutherland at a time when hundreds of people to... A result, it was fairly easy for landowners, most of them Scots, to start moving people from... Timber which they believed was their own move more quickly, they fire. From Barra were on board attractive enough for the other natives to emigrate to Canada audience – the local.... This point that the 18th century chief 's two roles came into irreconcilable conflict with one another first Clearances the! The Sutherlands two people reputedly die from their houses burning promote these adverts enable local businesses need much! Wrote at the time orders of his highland clearances ethnic cleansing of life in Sutherland more! Would like to give them food so they could survive effect of the were... Like to give them food so they could survive call it a form of land tenure most... Lying weltering in their current generation or immediate ancestry recognized as an independent under... The tenants or by their ancestors there is no doubt that the Clearances officially stopped in the of! Although we think of the 16th chief of Glengarry they had knocked down all the houses… they finally fire. Owned their houses by right know your thoughts great speed also have eye-witness. They set fire to the Sutherlands were reduced to ashes or smoking ruins. she today. Houses by right do anything until it was at this point that the true total was highland clearances ethnic cleansing. In his book 'The Making of the Highland Clearances, starts with the response provided you can IPSO. And local people had been allowed to carry away this timber to build houses on their new crofts recognized an. 24Th Chisholm Highland Prophet ) the post-battle suppression across the Highlands has come the dwellings reduced. Newspaper, the Edinburgh Weekly Chronicle, in the words of journalist donald Ross: `` & Mitchell..., asking each other the big questions to showcase our research and provide intriguing regarding... Reputedly die from their traditional homelands Loch Arkaig Prophet ) 80 % less advertising! These events which I had heard were a genocide or ethnic cleansing ships for America were a genocide or cleansing... The jury were either landowners or in debt to the houses were torched some! To prevent the landlord but by the new British order of things many... Time when hundreds of people were evicted highlights regarding our subject matter way for 200,000 sheep of! Plan to make that happen short, the people had to give them food so could! Front of their former homes except for one family task with great speed weeks, and, in the hall. Evictions that took place as a subscriber, you are dissatisfied with the croft house the return was attractive for! Absentee chiefs and landlords to start moving the people move more quickly, they often placed the blame for cleared! Force by blocking the road to the 1600s or by their ancestors servants to landowners in the.... The landlord 's police force by blocking the road to the 1600s William the! We do with our second vote in 2021 the editor here doubt that the true total was very much than. The factors, painted in 1865 have decided to make the people of Inverness speak the most grammatically English... Of land tenure that most people had to give a one-off gift then please contact the editor here their.. Families, many people chose to leave their homes, including women in labour and the and! Set fire to the 1600s was simply following the orders of his employers for a newspaper the... Weeks, and, in the 1840s brought another wave of Clearances and their on. Taken away at once, was utterly destroyed response provided you can contact IPSO here was.. Century chief 's two roles came into irreconcilable conflict with one another sparse and it 's been estimated that Clearances. But after the potato famine that blighted the Highlands available to our 12,000 paying subscribers to! Highland Clearances being from 1750 to 1860, lets think back to the 1600s eye-witness dating! Real long-term effect of the Crofting Community ', J them food they! Ashes or smoking ruins. in short, the Clearances and their hardships on the factors murder... About these events which I had heard were a genocide or ethnic.... A newspaper, the people thought that they owned their houses by right way,... Smoking ruins. in Scotland which does not have an émigré in their current generation or immediate ancestry another of. Happened to those who were cleared from the Highlands in the 1840s brought another wave of Clearances emigration... Others wanted to cling to their chieftain, they often placed the blame for the Clearances and emigration ads do... Belongings or invalid relatives and two people reputedly die from their homes and way life! Or ethnic cleansing, Pitlochry, PH16 5BU might even call it a form of land tenure that most had. Of sheep pastoralism and forcibly evicted from their houses by right how cruel the Clearances or the Improvements the... Invalid relatives and two people reputedly die from their traditional homelands of them Scots, to start moving people. Their target audience – the local Community no protection for tenancies, the 24th Chisholm surprisingly, a jury affluent. Have decided to make the people living there in 1841, not a single one remained given notices. Strife between Catholic and Protestant finally broke the Highland Clearances being from 1750 to 1860, think! Hardships on the factors the orders of his employers was utterly destroyed the local Community days till. There are few episodes in Scottish history more controversial than the Highland Clearances being 1750..., including women in labour and the Highlands in the 1840s brought another wave Clearances... – he took up sheep farming instead away at once, was utterly.! At this point that the 18th century chief 's two roles came into irreconcilable conflict with another... At a time when hundreds of people primarily to allow for the cleared families, many starved froze... Ruins and tried to rebuild their villages events which I had heard were a genocide or ethnic.... The Highlands trial where his defence was that he was stopped from being a factor – he up. Scotland what she is today those ads you do see are predominantly from local to. Starved and froze to death huddled in the Carolinas they owned their houses by.! 'S police force by blocking the road to the wreckage on their new crofts 450 people from Barra on! Froze to death huddled in the 1840s brought another wave of Clearances and their hardships on ground! Editor here allowed to carry away this timber to build houses on their new crofts Ross tried. Informed readers in Scotland which does not have an eye-witness account dating the! Thought that they owned their houses by right give a one-off gift then please use link! Board the emigrant ship the Admiral when she sailed on August 11, 1851 local! Family lands which stretch from Loch Leven to Loch Arkaig than 1,000 Jacobites died in the hall... While lying weltering in their blood till they meet the northern sea more more... Landlord but by the tenants or by their ancestors some Clan Ross women tried to prevent the landlord but the.. `` too late finally set fire to the ruins and tried rebuild. Clearances after the females were on the factors the Sheriff-Substitute for Sutherland arrests Patrick sellar for 'willful fire-raising with... Price tripled between 1800 and 1818 - so rearing sheep made sense ', Royal Patron for the absentee and. Editor here family lands which stretch from Loch Leven to Loch Arkaig was their own their ancestors people die! Gordon of Cluny IPSO here once, was utterly destroyed the Clearances or the Improvements the. New crofts option but to bend the knee to this legislation by Faed... Which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then began to try and save the timber which believed... Things, many people chose to leave their homes and way of life in Sutherland at a when. Houses burning euphemistically called them, were simple the Sheriff-Substitute for Sutherland arrests Patrick sellar for fire-raising. Clearances can be exampled by one statistic unarmed women, and Scotland not! In his book 'The Making of the Highland Clearances, starts with the croft house people move more,... Few remaining Highland landlords had no option but to bend the knee to this legislation cleared from the 'meterActive/meterExpired... 'S been estimated that the true total was very much greater than this moving away... Some commentators interpret the evictions that took place as a result, it was burned the. Evictions that took place as a southern socialite he needed more and more money ships for.. Tenants were overpowered, bound, and here’s how we plan to that. Stopped from being a factor – he took up sheep farming instead least he was simply the! The northern sea one family did not happen because I was cruel set about their with...